About Fair Housing Find a manager that fits your property
Find a Manager Match me with a property managerMatch Me With a Manager I'm a Manager

Property Managers in St. Augustine, FL

Compare top property management companies in St. Augustine, FL. Review services and vetting status, then reach out or request a free quote.

Walter Williams Property Management, Inc.
Tripp Williams Office Manager
Jacksonville, FL [ Serves Jacksonville, Palm Coast, Middleburg, Orange Park +1 more ]
Verified & Vetted Long-term Residential
Full Property Management Services from leasing to day to day management of single family homes.
›
Bill Pacetti Realty, Inc.
Bill Pacetti Real Estate Broker, NARPM, HR.
St. Augustine, FL [ Serves Crescent Beach, Saint Augustine, Saint Augustine Beach, St. Augustine ]
Unverified
We manage homes, apartments, condos and commercial properties. Call us with all your rentals and property management needs. In business over 25 years. We do evictions, clean up and repairs for new and old owners.
›
Realty Select Services, LLC
Nancy Maggiore
Saint Johns, FL [ Serves Jacksonville, Fruit Cove, Orange Park, Saint Johns +1 more ]
Unverified
Realty Select Services, LLC was founded in 2006 by Broker/Owner Nancy Maggiore. Nancy has over 15 years of experience in residential and commercial property management and leasing and sales. As an owner of residential investment properties, she has developed a company philosophy and company procedures with both the investor and tenant's needs in mind. Both tenants and property owners can "Refer With Confidence"
›
Davidson Property Management
Anna Decker
St. Augustine, FL
Unverified
›
Davidson Realty
Shelby Heinemann
St. Augustine, FL
Unverified
›

Rental market in St. Augustine: a mixed ownership base

Renters occupy 42.8% of homes in St. Augustine, a mixed ownership base. The same data shows vacancy near 5.3%. The typical home is valued near $339,300, and the median household earns about $75,780 a year, with renters spending a median 35.3% of income on rent.

Market at a glance

Rents & affordability

35.3% Rent-to-income

People & households

42.8% Renter-occupied
42,904 Population
$75,780 Median household income

Housing stock

5.3% Vacancy rate
$339,300 Median home value
1986 Median year built
62.1% Single-family homes

Jobs

4.6% Unemployment rate
Who rents vs owns
Renters 42.8% Owners 57.2%

A good property management company in St. Augustine can take a load off your plate: pricing, marketing, tenant screening, rent collection, and maintenance. About 62.1% of local housing is single-family, a common focus for rental owners. With vacancy near 5.3%, rent positioning and days on market can shape your return. Area unemployment is 4.6% as of August 2026. Compare the managers above and request a free quote.

All rent figures cover long-term residential leases, not short-term or vacation stays. Commercial rents are not listed, but they generally follow local residential movement, so the signal above still applies to you.

Frequently asked questions

Is St. Augustine a good market for rental property?

It depends on your goals, and the fundamentals here are generally solid. Renters make up 42.8% of households and vacancy sits near 5.3%.

How strong is rental demand in St. Augustine?

Renters occupy 42.8% of homes, across a population of 42,904. Vacancy runs near 5.3%.

What do homes and incomes look like in St. Augustine?

A typical home here runs about $339,300. The median household income is about $75,780, and renters spend a median 35.3% of income on rent.

Why hire a property manager in St. Augustine?

A professional manager in St. Augustine can take the day-to-day off your plate, from tenant screening and rent collection to maintenance and local compliance.

Rent shown as a deviation from the typical U.S. rent, a national average weighted by renter population, from HERO and HUD reference data. Demographics, population, and rent trend from the U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020-2024 5-year estimates at the county level. Unemployment from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (August 2026).