About Fair Housing Find a manager that fits your property
Find a Manager Match me with a property managerMatch Me With a Manager I'm a Manager

Property Managers in Casselberry, FL

Compare top property management companies in Casselberry, FL. Review services and vetting status, then reach out or request a free quote.

Bell and Associates Realty, Inc.
H David Bell Broker
Winter Park, FL [ Serves Orlando, Apopka, Altamonte Springs, Oviedo +4 more ]
Unverified
    Independently owned and operated, over 25 years in the property management business, BBB  A+  Accredited Rating. Excellent tenant retention record,    
›
R.Russell Properties, Inc.
Mark C. Pagdin REALTOR, NARPM
Altamonte Springs, FL [ Serves Tampa, Orlando, Deltona, Kissimmee +14 more ]
Unverified Multi-Agent Team
Who is Russell Properties, Inc.? R. Russell Properties, Inc. is "Central Florida's Choice. With the same owner, in the same location, it's been a central Florida choice for twenty six years. Who are we? We are a family-oriented, full service-based real estate company that specializes in property management, sales and investments. Robert C. Russell is the principal owner and broker and has been in the real estate industry in Florida since 1978. As experienced Realtors, Rob Russell and the members of his staff are qualified to provide the professional real estate services needed to manage, lease, buy, or sell your real estate investment. Our clients enjoy a wide range of services and benefit from our many years of experience in marketing, negotiating, financing and contracts. We are committed to providing prompt, personal service. Our goal is to treat each investment property, each owner and tenant simply with the individual care and attention they deserve. We have extensive knowledge of the Florida and Central Florida area and offer our clients the finest in professional, reliable service. Russell Properties has grown into an industry leader by providing our clients with the highest caliber of service, strong attention to detail , state of the art management techniques and highly competitive pricing. Our staff of 10 professionals have served and assisted thousands of satisfied owners, tenants and clients, some whom have been with us for over 20 years. Please check us out at: www.russellproperties.com
›
Legends Realty
Tina Lopez GRI, Broker/Owner
Lake Mary, FL [ Serves Deltona, Apopka, Sanford, Altamonte Springs +9 more ]
Unverified
Offering Full Service Property Management. Specializing in the fields of renting Single Family Homes, Townhouses and Condos in Seminole, Orange, and West Volusia Counties of Central Florida. - Free Rental Analysis - We are open 7 days a week and are available to show properties - We market your property by placing advertisements on www.CentralFLRentals.com and numerous other online websites where potential tenants can view your home, yard signs (where allowed) and local newspapers - We have qualified real estate licensed agents - Video property inspections on move in and move out - Tenant screening on every adult rental application, Eviction Search through out Florida, Criminal Background Check on adult applicants, Residential verification from former landlords, References, Employment verification and Credit reports. Qualifying the potential tenant through the right procedures makes a huge difference - We use only attorney prepared leases - Computerized Accounting, Monthly Statements, End of the Year Statements, 1099 reporting statement. Our accounting department will have all the numbers for your tax return.
›
Allegiant Management Group
Maria Napolitano
Kissimmee, FL [ Serves Orlando, Kissimmee, Apopka, Sanford +9 more ]
Unverified Long-term Residential
Advanced Management Specialists provides superiorproperty management servicesthroughout theCentral Florida area. We are the leader in helping owners reach their investment property goals, as well as providing renters with the best possible choice in housing. We are ready and dedicated to take care of all your property management, rental, and sales needs. Our staff consists of qualified, highly trained professionals committed to excellence in customer service. From our front office staff, to our maintenance crew, as well as our dedicated property supervisors, accountants, and management personnel, we will handle any and all property management concerns with your peace of mind as our primary goal. Stop in and see why we are the premier property management company in Central Florida. Our office is conveniently located in the heart of Kissimmee close to major highways which gives usthe ability to easilyaccess to any part of Central Florida.
›
Fla Rent, Inc.
Robert Vazquez
Casselberry, FL
Unverified Long-term Residential
›
Park Avenue Previews
Virginia E. Cozy
Casselberry, FL
Unverified
›

Rental market in Casselberry: rising rents

In Casselberry, Census median gross rent rose about 43.6% over the last five years, rents on a clear upward path. The market also shows three-bedroom rents about 7% above the U.S. average, a population of 481,470, up 4.3% over five years, and renters in 33.8% of homes. The typical home is valued near $386,900, and the median household earns about $85,761 a year, with renters spending a median 34.4% of income on rent.

Market at a glance

Rents & affordability

+10% 2-bed vs U.S. rent
+7% 3-bed vs U.S. rent
+10% 4-bed vs U.S. rent
+43.6% Rent trend, 5-yr
34.4% Rent-to-income

People & households

33.8% Renter-occupied
481,470 Population
+4.3% Population, 5-yr
$85,761 Median household income

Housing stock

6.2% Vacancy rate
$386,900 Median home value
1988 Median year built
69.5% Single-family homes

Jobs

4.6% Unemployment rate
Rent vs the U.S. average, by bedroom size
U.S. average 2-bed +10% 3-bed +7% 4-bed +10%
Who rents vs owns
Renters 33.8% Owners 66.2%

In Casselberry, a professional property manager can take on pricing, marketing, screening, collections, and upkeep so you do not have to. About 69.5% of local housing is single-family, a common focus for rental owners. With vacancy near 6.2%, rent positioning and days on market can shape your return. Area unemployment is 4.6% as of August 2026. Browse the managers here and request pricing.

Pricing shown is long-term residential, not short-term or vacation. Non-residential and commercial rents follow the same local direction as a rule, so the residential deviations above give you a fair read.

Frequently asked questions

Are rents rising in Casselberry?

Over the last five years, Census median gross rent rose roughly 43.6%.

How do rents in Casselberry compare to the national average?

Compared with the U.S. average: two-bedroom +10%, three-bedroom +7%, four-bedroom +10%. Each figure compares a bedroom size to the typical U.S. rent, not a rent we set.

Is Casselberry a good market for rental property?

This market has seen rents increase, an advantage for a well-timed purchase. Renters make up 33.8% of households and vacancy sits near 6.2%. Three-bedroom rents run about 7% above the national average, and rents rose about 43.6% over five years.

How strong is rental demand in Casselberry?

About 33.8% of homes are renter-occupied, and the population of 481,470 grew 4.3% over five years. Vacancy runs near 6.2%.

Rent shown as a deviation from the typical U.S. rent, a national average weighted by renter population, from HERO and HUD reference data. Demographics, population, and rent trend from the U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2020-2024 5-year estimates at the county level, with the five-year trend measured against the 2015-2019 estimates. Unemployment from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (August 2026).